We Offer Fast Service
and Low Flat-Rate Shipping

Even though postage costs have increased, we are still offering low shipping rates.  Relax and enjoy our flat rate first class shipping - just $5.95 ships your entire order!

Most orders are processed to be shipped within five business days, and First Class Mail delivery can take from one to ten days depending on where in the country you live, so we also offer Priority Mail service as an added option for quicker shipping after processing.  Delivery always takes longer around holidays, so please order early.

Store Policies

Please be sure to check the spelling twice on all personalized items before placing your order, as we cannot be held responsible for any spelling errors that were submitted with the order, and we cannot accept returns, exchanges, or order cancellations on personalized merchandise.

If an error is made on our part, we will promptly exchange it for an identical item with the same personalization.  If this is your first time ordering from The Tooth Fairy Pillow Shoppe, you will really enjoy reading our customer testimonials ...

Payment Safety and Security

Your financial transactions are secure!  The Tooth Fairy Pillow Shoppe uses SSL (Secure Socket Layer) encryption when transmitting your payment information.

Payment Choices


Personalization

The personalization pictured on all the tooth fairy pillow pockets throughout our website is a computer font, which is only meant to show where the name is personalized on the pocket. 

Every Tooth Fairy Pillow is carefully personalized by hand with a permanent fabric paint pen in black to make the name stand out, then stars or hearts are added in a coordinating color - they are adorable!

Pay Less Than Everyone Else!

Sign up below to join The Tooth Fairy Pillow Shoppe's Customer Loyalty Program, then once a month, we'll email a special code that you can use one time during that month that will automatically take 10% off every Tooth Fairy Pillow you order from The Tooth Fairy Pillow Shoppe.

But there's more!  Twice a year, at Easter and Christmas, our Customer Loyalty Members will receive an offer for a free letter from the Easter Bunny and Santa, personalized with their child's name.  This is a rewards program that we've been doing for several years now, and the kids, parents, and grandparents rave about it.  It's just our way of saying thanks for your business all year long!